By Eric Ditzian
Last March, as it became increasingly clear Simon Cowell didn't give a hoot and Ellen DeGeneres' nice-gal charm didn't translate well to reality competition judging, I wrote a story headlined, "Is Kara DioGuardi The Best 'American Idol' Judge?"
"She's consistently given out the most insightful criticism, displayed the most informed ear and dolled out [...]Giuliana DePandi
